4.16 In the case of an extension or conversion to a historic farmstead, non-designated building in a conservation area, or listed building, the applicant must demonstrate that the proposal respects the character and appearance of the building and does not substantially harm its significance or setting. Impact on surrounding heritage assets will also need to be considered (see C.2.ii Heritage Assets).
4.17 In cases where the structural condition of a building is in question, a full structural survey by a qualified architect or structural engineer will be required prior to application.
4.18 The original function of farm, industrial and other traditional buildings must be legible when converted.
4.19 When converting a traditional building, the fundamental plan and massing must be maintained, and insertion of new openings, or blocking of existing features, must be kept to a minimum. Where changes are proposed, these must be accompanied by a clear statement of need and assessment of impact on significance.
4.20 Checklist for conversions of agricultural, industrial and other traditional buildings for residential use:
Click to zoom in
4.21 The Lake District has a strong and varied sense of place, derived from many factors including its natural beauty, historic character, and cultural associations. These combine together to create memorable places where people want to live, work and visit. On a local level, understanding the physical, cultural and spiritual factors that shape place identity is a critical first step in the design of developments that preserve and enhance local character and make a positive contribution to placemaking.
4.22 Local character is derived from the interaction of many factors — built form, landscape, public spaces, history, nature, and cultural associations, as well as less tangible aspects like a sense of community.
4.23 The applicant must demonstrate and clearly articulate how the proposed development respects or enhances local character and distinctiveness. This must be informed by an understanding of the site context, including any historic character assessment required to support the application.
An example of a farm where the farmhouse is limewashed whereas the farm buildings are left as bare stone
The classic hierarchy of materials: a limewashed and render farmhouse, a bare stone barn and the hardest to course stones used for the boundary wall.
4.24 The type, form and composition of new buildings must be rooted in local character. Where development sits within the historic core of a settlement, design must reflect the local vernacular tradition (where buildings were designed to meet functional needs). This varies across the Lake District in response to changes in the underlying geology, that influences not only the choice of local building material, but also built forms and methods of construction.
4.25 Information on common vernacular forms, and their distribution across the Lake District, can be found in the Supporting Information. Each settlement has a distinct architectural tradition depending on several factors, but common characteristics are:
4.26 Although these features are common there are many variations according to location and the applicant must demonstrate that their designs respond appropriately to the specific traditions of the area. This is not intended to stifle contemporary design or encourage pastiche, but simply show how a design has been inspired by local character.
In the 18th century, polite architecture without render covering the stone would have been unthinkable. Hawkshead.
An uncommon example of a converted barn with limewash over the stonework. The shapes of the different materials can still be seen through the coating.
Click to zoom in
4.27 In areas where there is a wider variety of architectural styles, particularly those areas of 19th and early 20th century expansion around the edges of towns, design cues should still be taken from the prevailing architectural forms of the area, although there is potentially far more flexibility in design. However, detailing should be consistent with architectural style, and mixing features within a building should be avoided. In all cases, design must be informed by analysis of context and local character.
Click to zoom in
4.28 The pitch or angle of a roof has a large impact on how a building looks and fits in with its surroundings. The roof pitches of new development must respond positively to its townscape context, for example, by matching neighbouring buildings.
4.29 Where slates are used roof pitches must not be lower than 22.5º. If the slates are laid shallower than this, rain will run off more slowly and can find its way under and between slates.
4.30 The roof pitches of extensions, particularly catslide roofs that are often found in the Lake District, should match or be similar to the roof pitch of the main roof of the building.
4. The roof pitch of the catslide roof can either continue the slope of the main roof or be slightly shallower (e.g. by 5º) to slow runoff and increase headroom under the catslide roof.
5. Lean-to extensions should generally have the same or a similar roof pitch to the main roof of the building.
Click to zoom in
4.31 The ratio of the height to width of a window sets the shape and proportion of window openings. New development such as extensions must incorporate window proportions that show a positive response to their context, by reflecting the proportions of the existing building.
4.32 In this example:
4.33 The number of windows and the spacing of windows on an elevation has a big impact on how a building looks. Most houses in the Lake District have a rhythm of evenly spaced window openings that give elevations a pleasing and balanced appearance.
4.34 In this example:
4. The right-hand part of the elevation looks noticeably ‘busier’ than the rest of the house due to the number of small windows squashed into this part of the building. It detracts from the character of the whole elevation.
5. All parts of the building have a similar layout of windows giving a harmonious appearance
4.35 One of the most important ways of establishing a sense of place in the built environment is through the use of materials, most importantly through roof and wall materials. These should be complemented with an approach to windows, doors, landscaping and boundaries which reflect the quality and character of the landscape and the importance of the built environment.
4.36 Unlike other areas of the country where building materials are often imported or manufactured, the appearance of buildings in the Lake District is a direct product of the geology beneath them.
4.37 Whether it is distinctively pink Eskdale granite or the greens and greys of Honister stone in the centre of Keswick, when planning a design for an extension or new building in the Lake District, looking at the roofs and walls of neighbouring buildings will inform the most appropriate approach.
Cobbles harmonise visually with quarried stone.
Cobbles lend a rural character to paved areas.
River cobbles are a colourful and attractive alternative to paving stones in hard landscaping. Hawkshead.
4.38 The colour and textures of new development must harmonise with local character and landscape, although this does not prevent the use of both to add focus and interest to the streetscape where justified.
Render finishes were reserved for the higher status buildings, such as this farmhouse, while barns and outbuildings were usually left as bare stone. Borrowdale.
Farm buildings often have a ‘rougher’ appearance than houses due to the bare stone. Here the external staircase is barely visible against the stonework. Hawkshead
Here the farmhouse has a smooth render with lines struck into it to give the appearance of regular stone blocks. The adjacent barn has been left as bare sandstone (stained by a broken downpipe).
4.39 The walls of a building can often be as important to local distinctiveness, character and sense of place as its roof, especially within a dense town context or a tightly knit farm group when seen from road level. Wall finishes are functional, decorative and often both. Wall finishes are functional, decorative and often both.
4.40 Local walling materials vary more obviously across the Lake District than roofing slate. Stone is less easy to transport and therefore historically, the easiest stone to build a house from was the closest available. Walls were often built upon boulders or bedrock, with stone quarried from the nearest rock face or gathered from the land or nearby streams.
4.41 The most common stone used in the core of the Lake District is slate stone, the by-product of the roofing slates quarried across the area. Limestone, granite and red sandstone are found towards the different peripheries of the Lake District, away from the slate-rich mountains.
4.42 Where possible, stone used for the walls of buildings should match the type, appearance and method of laying that is most prevalent in the area.
Click to zoom in
4.43 Roughcast render or ‘wet-dash’, or modern products which replicate its appearance, is the other most common walling finish. Roughcast render is used throughout the Lake District and its use as a wall finish is likely to be appropriate on a range of buildings, particularly where it is not possible to obtain stone to match nearby buildings. Although ‘dry-stone’ construction is often perceived as a quintessential feature of the Lake District it is in some areas a late 19th and 20th-century decorative design choice. As always, cues should be taken from the surrounding area.
Another lime-based material, roughcast render, was used to cover stone and give a neater looking elevation.
It is called ‘roughcast’ because pebbles are mixed in with the lime to give a larger surface area for water to evaporate from in wet conditions.
Roughcast render is found across the Lake District. Image: Burlington Slate Ltd.
The combination of roughcast render, local slate and local stone boundary walls gives buildings a distinctly local character. Image: Burlington Slate Ltd.
Roughcast render is usually covered by a number of coats of limewash. Here is its bare appearance.
4.44 Agricultural buildings, with the exception of farmhouses, were generally not traditionally rendered in the Lake District. This made a clear distinction between domestic and functional space. Unless evidence can be demonstrated on the building itself or through research, former agricultural buildings must not be rendered.
4.45 The acceptability of alternative materials will depend on the sensitivity of the site and nature of the design. It will be necessary to demonstrate that the use of materials other than local stone and roughcast render is appropriate.
4.46 Metal wall cladding (including zinc, copper, lead, stainless steel and aluminium) and timber wall cladding or composite cladding products which mimic the appearance of timber are only likely to be acceptable where used sparingly as part of a cohesive design solution and where the context of the site and character of the landscape means that its use would not compromise sense of place.
The distinctive green-grey-brown local stone is used for walling across much of the Lake District. Image: Burlington Slate Ltd.
Locally quarried green stone walling combined with red sandstone that may well have been quarried at or near St Bees, Cumbria.
Lake District green slate was used in the mid-20th century to give modern buildings like this former bank a distinctive local character.
Local blue grey slate stone is a by-product of the local roof slate industry and is used for walling. Image: Burlington Slate Ltd
The local blue grey slate stone has a distinctive appearance and is still quarried in Cumbria..
4.47 Most locally distinctive of all are the local slate roofs of the Lake District that can be seen covering the majority of buildings in the area and which make a significant contribution to sense of place, particularly when seen from above.
Click to zoom in
Blue grey slate is one of the local naturally occurring building materials of the Lake District. Ravenglass. Image: Burlington Slate Ltd
Local blue grey slate is traditionally laid in courses that increase in size towards the eaves. Image: Burlington Slate Ltd
Local blue grey slate is a locally distinctive building material that is still quarried in Cumbria. Image: Burlington Slate Ltd
The difference between local blue grey slate (left) and imported Spanish (right) slate is visible. Image: Burlington Slate Ltd
Hawkshead has a highly harmonious appearance due to the consistent use of local blue grey slate roofing. Image: Burlington Slate Ltd
4.48 Roofing material used in both new build and conversions must be locally sourced green or blue-grey slate. Laid in a traditional pattern of diminishing courses (where larger slates at the eaves gradually recede to the smallest slates at the ridge) and random widths, local slate has a thick gauge, rough-hewed surface and distinctive patina which all contribute to an appearance that is as locally distinctive when first laid as it is decades later.
4.49 The use of local green slate or blue grey slate will be informed by the immediate context of the site. Often, either option will be acceptable.
4.50 Other types of roofing material, even alternative forms of slate, weather very differently and do not harmonise with the landscape in the same way.
4.51 Alternative roof coverings to local slate will only be considered in the following circumstances:
4.52 Imported slate is not an appropriate alternative to local slate. Imported slate is likely to retain a smooth and uniform colour and texture which means it does not weather in the same way as local slates and as they are normally made to standard sizes and to a thinner gauge, they cannot replicate the variety found in a local slate roof and cannot replicate its appearance.
Local to the Lake District, this green-grey slate has a distinctive colour, and is laid in diminishing courses. Image: Burlington Slate Ltd
The local green slate is traditionally laid in diminishing courses. Image: Burlington Slate Ltd
Green slate continues to be quarried locally, so it can continue to give new development a local character. Image: Burlington Slate Ltd
In some parts of the Lake District, as here in Hawkshead, slate is hung on walls for protection from prevailing winds.
4.53 Even where planning permission is not required for replacement or repair of an existing roof, we strongly discourage the use of imported slate for the above reasons and because the incremental effect of changes which do not require planning permission is the erosion of local distinctiveness, character and sense of place.
4.54 If there are valid reasons to consider roof coverings other than local slate, alternative locally produced roofing materials are likely to be more appropriate than imported slate, when considered in terms of its appearance, longevity, value for money and carbon footprint.
2.76 Local stone should also be used for primary boundary walls, especially in rural areas. The type and nature of traditional boundary divisions should be identified as part of the historic character and landscape assessments. Drystone or quarried stone should be used in preference to sawn stone for boundary walls.
2.77 Hard landscaping should be kept to a minimum and must take cues from the surrounding area, subject to associated constraints such as drainage and durability. The choice of surface must harmonise with local character particularly in terms of colour.
Grey limestone is a material quarried around the southern fringes of the Lake District and used for walls and buildings. Image: Burlington Slate Ltd.
Here the boundary wall incorporates boulders of the local blue-grey stone, giving a particularly rural character.
Resources
Nature
Movement
